Expert Opinion

This page covers two separate services: liability reviews and plaintiff assessments. Details for each are set out below.

Areas of expertise

Associate Professor Tucker reviews legal briefs for defence and plaintiff legal teams regarding the following areas of practice:

  • Obstetrics across a range of facility levels, from level 2 (only delivering babies 37 weeks’ gestation or higher, low-risk obstetrics) to level 6 (all babies below 29 weeks’ gestation, including high-risk obstetrics and extremely premature babies).

  • Stillbirth, preterm labour, medical complications of pregnancy and birth resulting in cerebral palsy.

  • Outpatient antenatal care, including GP-shared care, interfacing with hospital midwives, midwifery group practices, private practice midwives and doulas.

  • Management of routine and complex labour and delivery conducted in the birth suite and operating theatre setting, including instrumental delivery and complex caesarean section, including caesarean hysterectomy.

  • Provision of advice from a high-level obstetric facility to low-level hospitals. Planning and coordinating patient retrievals over large physical distances.

  • Outpatient and procedural gynaecology.

  • Surgical gynaecology, including day surgery and inpatient settings. Open surgery and laparoscopic operations for intermediate-level endometriosis and hysterectomy. Miscarriage, ectopic pregnancy and surgical complication management.

  • Leadership, decision-making and clinical governance.

  • Appropriate supervision of trainees, including Registrars and Resident Medical Officers.

Areas not within scope

  • Urogynaecology.

  • Advanced laparoscopic surgery, e.g. deep, infiltrating endometriosis (AGES level 5/6) and robot-assisted surgery.

  • Gynaecological oncology.

  • Maternal-Fetal Medicine subspecialty practice.

  • IVF and reproductive medicine.

If you’re unsure, please reach out by email with a brief, records review and operation report or relevant correspondence.

Liability reviews

Engagement process

Associate Professor Tucker is happy to receive preliminary emails to confirm that a matter for review falls within his area of expertise, if the information on this page does not make that clear.

A brief is required to commence a formal engagement. Providing a brief enables:

  1. Final confirmation that he is suitably qualified to comment on the matter.

  2. Exclusion of conflicts of interest.

  3. Fee estimate for file review, if needed, before booking.

Following these checks, a booking link will be sent by email, enabling your team to request a mutually convenient appointment time. A calendar invite will follow.

Accept the calendar invite to confirm the appointment. Invites can be shared within your organisation and contain the videoconference link.

All meetings are held by video conference via Microsoft Teams.

Contact: admin@dannytucker.net

Fees for liability reviews

A typical review of clinical records up to ~500 pages entails 2.5 hours of pre-reading and formulation and 45 minutes of video conference. The fee for this is 3.25 x $850 p/h = $2762.50+GST, which is a minimum fee. A longer, more complex review might involve 3.5 hours of pre-reading, usually offset by report-writing time. 

If a team wishes to proceed, report turnaround is 5-6 weeks. Report fees depend upon the complexity of the case and the number of questions in the letter of instruction. A quotation for the report can be provided after file review, but generally, 7-9 hours is typical for medium complexity (same hourly rate as above).

An expedited report is available for urgent matters; please reach out for further information on availability and any supplementary fees.

If a team decides not to proceed with a report, a client-friendly summary of the opinion and Q&A for use without specific attribution is offered. This is provided without additional fee as a service to clients who have invested deeply, emotionally, and often financially in a case.

Please note opinions are not given based on a legal team’s medical records review, solitary expert opinions, or CTGs without case notes. This inevitably leads to uncertainty, excessive qualifications, or hedging. In complete case reviews, relevant information not previously identified is often discovered.

For pregnancy reviews, it is optimal to receive antenatal records from all involved care providers, formal ultrasound reports (not images), intrapartum and postnatal records, including CTGs, blood investigations, surgical records, and, where possible, prior pregnancy notes. Baby resuscitation records enable me to evaluate the neonatal condition at birth, evidence of later deterioration, and imaging to inform an opinion on causation.

Plaintiff assessments

Associate Professor Tucker accepts a limited number of instructions to assess plaintiffs in obstetric and gynaecological matters. These are offered separately from liability reviews and on different terms.

What is offered

  • Permanent impairment assessment under AMA Guides, 4th edition (AMA4). This is the only impairment methodology offered. Legal teams should confirm that AMA4 meets the requirements of the relevant scheme before instructing.

  • Condition and prognosis, future treatment, and care needs reports where no impairment rating is required, limited to conditions within his clinical scope as listed above.

  • Assessments are conducted by video conference only, from Queensland. In-person examinations are not offered. Where the question asked cannot be answered without a physical examination, he will say so at the preliminary stage so the legal team can make other arrangements for that aspect.

Availability

Instructions are being accepted now. The earliest available assessment date is February 2027. Availability is limited, and appointments are offered in order of confirmed instruction.

Engagement process

  • Email a preliminary enquiry describing the matter and the questions to be answered. He will confirm whether it falls within his expertise and whether a video assessment is suitable.

  • A letter of instruction is required to open a formal engagement. This enables qualification and conflicts-of-interest checks and a fee estimate.

  • Records should be provided as a single indexed and paginated bundle, with the instructing solicitor identifying the documents considered relevant to the questions asked. Any existing chronology or records summary is welcome.

  • A booking link is then emailed for the assessment appointment. The calendar invitation includes the video conference link, and the legal team is responsible for ensuring the client can join.

  • Records must be received at least two weeks before the assessment date or the appointment will be rescheduled.

Fees

Assessment fees are time-based at $850 per hour plus GST. There is no fixed report fee. A fee estimate is provided after the records have been reviewed. The estimate assumes a bundle of up to about 500 pages. Where the records exceed this, a revised estimate is provided before the review proceeds. Review time reflects the records relevant to the questions asked; the report records what was reviewed. Time is charged for three components:

  • Review of the records before the assessment.

  • The video assessment interview, booked for 60 minutes.

  • Preparation of the report.

Where the client does not attend, or the appointment is cancelled with less than three business days’ notice, the booked interview time is charged.

Reports are delivered within four weeks of the assessment date.

What the legal team needs to arrange

  • A private room where the client will not be interrupted or overheard.

  • A device with a working camera and microphone and a reliable internet connection.

  • Photo identification for the client to show at the start of the assessment.

  • An interpreter, where needed, arranged by the legal team.

  • Complete records, delivered at least two weeks before the appointment.

All meetings are held by video conference via Microsoft Teams.

Contact: admin@dannytucker.net